Navigating the Whiplash: Annuity Pricing and Strategy in a Volatile Rate Era
June 10, 2025
Market Watch
Next Move: What’s Ahead for Annuity Pricing, Product Availability, and Carrier Strategy After Rate Whiplash
The last twelve months have rewritten the rulebook for annuity pricing. Carriers, advisors, and clients alike are navigating a new era of interest rate volatility that’s reshaping how guarantees are priced, which products survive, and how insurers approach the next fiscal year.
This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Subscribed
Pricing: Constant Motion is the New Normal
We’ve entered the age of agile repricing. With yields jumping, dipping, and recalibrating weekly, carriers are compressing their pricing cycles—some updating rates biweekly or even daily. The result? Advisors must stay alert. One week’s best-in-class guarantee might be next week’s average offer. Expect spreads to tighten, caps to shift, and bonuses to disappear without warning.
Product Availability: Thinning the Herd
We’re watching a quiet product contraction unfold. While demand for MYGAs and fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) remains strong, carriers are pulling back on longer-duration products, high-liability income riders, and legacy contracts that strain reserves. Simplicity and scalability are now driving product development—leaner riders, more index options, shorter guarantees.
Noteworthy: At least four major carriers reduced premium limits on top-selling MYGAs in Q2, citing capacity and hedging strain.
Carrier Strategy: Flex, Don’t Break
Carriers are pivoting from "set it and forget it" models to adaptive frameworks. We’re seeing:
Expanded use of volatility-controlled indices.
Partnerships with third-party asset managers for capital efficiency.
Rollout of lower-commission, high-turnover annuities targeting fee-based RIAs.
These changes aren’t just reactive—they’re strategic plays to build margin resilience and distribution agility in an unpredictable rate cycle.
Product Pulse
Trending Up: Short-duration MYGAs (3–5 years), uncapped index strategies
Trending Down: Legacy GMIB riders, high upfront bonus contracts
By Daniel Mueller
Edditor of the Insurance Standard
follow me on Substack: @theinsurancestandard
